Home › All-in-one curricula › Comparisons
Two all-in-one homeschool curricula, compared on what actually decides the fit: subjects and math included, faith content, teaching style and how much you'll teach.
Updated September 2026 · based on parent reviews and publisher information
Still torn? Answer a few questions and see how both rank for your child, side by side.
Compare for my child| Master Books | The Good and the Beautiful | |
|---|---|---|
| Grades | PreK–12th | PreK–8th |
| Subjects | Separate packs for science, history/Bible/apologetics and language arts, plus its own math line (K-6 living math, high school algebra/geometry) — no single all-subjects box | Language arts, math, history (with US Constitution add-on), science, art and geography woven in |
| Math | Sold as an add-on by the same publisher | Included |
| Faith | Christian worldview throughout | Christian worldview throughout |
| Approach | Charlotte-Mason-flavored, story-driven curriculum packs per subject; young-earth Christian worldview throughout | Christian, literature-based: story-driven history/science plus scripted language arts and math |
| Who teaches | The parent teaches | The parent teaches |
| Parent prep | Low (open-and-go daily schedule built into each curriculum pack) | Low–moderate (open-and-go daily lessons, but parent leads and preps read-alouds) |
| Screen time | A mix of screen and paper | A mix of screen and paper |
| Video lessons | Available: master Books Academy offers supplemental videos for some courses, not required | Available: app-based audio/video supports some courses but isn't required for every subject |
| Cost | $170 est.: Grade 3 Math Lessons for a Living Education Level 3, plus one science pack and one history pack — bought separately, no single all-subjects price | $345: Grade 3 estimate — Math 3, Language Arts 3, History Year 1 set, and ~4 science units bought as separate courses |
| Parents love |
|
|
| Common complaints |
|
|
Independent reviewers are clear that Master Books is not a single boxed curriculum: science, history/Bible, apologetics and language arts are each sold as their own self-contained 'curriculum pack,' and math comes from a separate living-math line rather than being bundled in. Parents like the open-and-go daily schedules, full-color presentation and consistent young-earth Christian voice across every pack, and most describe layering two or three packs together plus math to build a full year rather than buying one box. The most common criticisms are a fixed 180-day schedule with no built-in flex days and occasional answer-key errors.
Reviewers consistently praise the artwork, engaging readers, and unusually thoughtful grammar and spelling design that avoids needless repetition. The most common complaint is a growing dependence on the companion app for core lessons in the upper levels, plus a lot of home printing if you skip the printed books. Because there's no single grade-level box, families assemble the year from several separate course purchases rather than one checkout.
Neither is better for every child. Master Books is the stronger fit for no, we'll add our own; one child at a time; minimal. The Good and the Beautiful is the stronger fit for literature-based read-alouds; yes, siblings together; some.
Master Books: sold as an add-on by the same publisher. The Good and the Beautiful: included.
Master Books: $170 est.: Grade 3 Math Lessons for a Living Education Level 3, plus one science pack and one history pack — bought separately, no single all-subjects price. The Good and the Beautiful: $345: Grade 3 estimate — Math 3, Language Arts 3, History Year 1 set, and ~4 science units bought as separate courses.
Summaries are in our own words.