Home › Civics & economics › How we rank
Every ranking on this site comes from your answers and a fixed set of published rules. No publisher can pay to change a score or a position.
Updated September 2026 · 14 programs and 4 supplements
For every program we read independent reviews (Cathy Duffy Reviews, homeschool blogs, retailer pages) and publisher materials, then record how it fits each answer in the quiz: what it covers (government, economics or personal finance), the viewpoint it teaches from, its teaching style (textbook, discussion, video or projects), whether it earns a high school credit, how much a parent teaches, and how it's delivered. Each fit gets a score from strongly negative to strongly positive, with a short reason. Every profile lists its sources.
Several programs have only one or two independent reviews. Where coverage is thin, the program's page says so and we show only what the sources support. We don't ask a learning-differences question for this subject.
Every question is optional. When you answer a question, only that question's rules count. If you choose "Prefer not to answer", "No preference" or skip it, that question is left out, so the more you answer, the more accurate the ranking. For each question, a program earns points from its own fit, compared with the best fit any program has for that answer.
| Question | How much it counts |
|---|---|
| Grade | A hard filter. A program that doesn't cover every grade you pick is capped at 15%. |
| What you want to cover · Viewpoint · Teacher involvement · Past programs | 1.5× (these decide most of the fit) |
| Teaching style · High school credit · Screen time | 1× |
| Video lessons | 0.5× |
Viewpoint is a question on its own because civics and economics courses often teach from a stated perspective: a Christian worldview, a free-market and limited-government view, or a nonpartisan approach. We tag each program by the viewpoint its publisher and reviewers describe. A program that matches the viewpoint you pick ranks higher; programs that don't state one count as neutral; and we never rank one viewpoint above another.
A program's points are divided by the best possible total for your answers, so 100% means it fits every answer as well as any program can. Two more rules apply:
If we ever earn money from a link, the disclosure page will say so, and the ranking rules above stay the same.
Rankings summarize what reviewers and publishers report. They can't know your child, and viewpoint tags reflect what the sources say, not a judgment about any political or religious position. Elementary grades have few options on our list. Use your shortlist as a starting point, look at samples, and trust what you see at your own table.