Home › History & geography › Comparisons
Two homeschool history programs, compared on what actually decides the fit: faith content, teaching style, what they cover, and how much you'll teach.
Updated September 2026 · based on parent reviews and publisher information
Still torn? Answer a few questions and see how both rank for your child, side by side.
Compare for my child| Build Your Library | Torchlight | |
|---|---|---|
| Grades | K–12th | K–8th |
| Faith | No religious content | No religious content |
| Covers | World history, American history | World history |
| Approach | Chronological living-books history: daily reading, narration and copywork drive the lesson, not a textbook | Literature-based, Socratic: real books and discussion questions carry history alongside other subjects |
| Who teaches | The parent teaches | The parent teaches from a scripted guide |
| Parent prep | Moderate (guide plans daily lessons; parent sources or borrows the books from the library) | Moderate (guide provided; parent gathers/borrows ~100 library books and preps discussion/projects) |
| Screen time | Mostly offline (books and paper) | Mostly offline (books and paper) |
| Video lessons | Available: occasional links to documentaries/online video, not required | None: no video lessons; parent reads and leads Socratic discussion from provided outlines |
| Cost | $39.95: Level 3 lesson-plan guide (36 weeks); book list is separate, most titles are available at the library | $47: Level 3 PDF guide (ages 8-12, 36 weeks); book list and math are separate, most titles available at the library |
| Parents love |
|
|
| Common complaints |
|
|
Secular homeschoolers pick Build Your Library because it pairs a Charlotte Mason approach (narration, copywork, real books) with an explicitly non-religious, chronological book list, and reviewers like that most titles can come from the library instead of a purchased box. The recurring complaint is that composition/writing instruction is thin and needs a separate program, and because you source the books yourself, actual cost and prep time depend heavily on what your library has on the shelf.
Secular families consistently praise Torchlight for pairing real, diverse literature with Socratic discussion questions that push kids past surface facts, and several call it one of the most affordable complete options since most books come from the library. The most common caution, including from Cathy Duffy, is that it teaches from an explicit secular-humanist worldview rather than a neutral one, and reviewers note the reading load is heavy and uneven week to week, with sourcing dozens of library books (and the late fees that can come with it) a real logistical task.
Neither is better for every child. Build Your Library is the stronger fit for story spine + activities; video lessons a big plus. Torchlight is the stronger fit for hands-on projects and unit studies.
Build Your Library: no religious content. Torchlight: no religious content.
Build Your Library: $39.95: Level 3 lesson-plan guide (36 weeks); book list is separate, most titles are available at the library. Torchlight: $47: Level 3 PDF guide (ages 8-12, 36 weeks); book list and math are separate, most titles available at the library.
Summaries are in our own words.