Home › Math › Comparisons
Two popular homeschool math programs, compared on what actually decides the fit: how your child learns, how much you'll teach, and how each one handles review.
Updated September 2026 · based on parent reviews and publisher information
Still torn? Answer a few questions and see how both rank for your child, side by side.
Compare for my child| Saxon Math | The Good and the Beautiful | |
|---|---|---|
| Grades | K–12 | PreK–middle school |
| Approach | Spiral / incremental | Gentle, integrated |
| Who teaches | Scripted for the parent | Scripted for the parent |
| Parent prep | Low (scripted) | Very low |
| Screen time | Mostly offline | Mostly offline |
| Video lessons | Available: official video lessons sold separately (Saxon Teacher) | Available: free lesson videos for some levels |
| Faith | No religious content | Christian content |
| Cost | About $152 for a homeschool kit (Saxon 5/4); textbook is reusable | About $59 per grade (course book $30 + math box $29) |
| Placement | Free placement tests | Free placement test |
| Parents love |
|
|
| Common complaints |
|
|
Parents like that it's clear, well organized, and tells you exactly what to do each day, and the built-in review keeps skills from fading. The most common complaints are that it's dry, with no color or fun, and that the repetition wears on kids who pick things up quickly. Several parents say the younger levels take more of their time than expected.
Parents love how beautiful and easy it is: open the book and follow the steps, with almost no prep. Cost is a big draw. Common concerns are that some kids need extra practice, and that the content is conservative and faith-based throughout. Families should know the author's religious affiliation before buying. Consumable books can't be reused for siblings.
Neither is better for every child. Saxon Math is the stronger fit for reading and working alone; lots of mixed review; no religious content. The Good and the Beautiful is the stronger fit for pictures and diagrams; stories and fun; christian worldview.
Saxon Math is spiral / incremental.
The Good and the Beautiful is gentle, integrated.
Saxon Math: About $152 for a homeschool kit (Saxon 5/4); textbook is reusable. The Good and the Beautiful: About $59 per grade (course book $30 + math box $29).
Summaries are in our own words.