Home › Science › Comparisons
Two homeschool science programs, compared on what actually decides the fit: creation and faith content, teaching style, and how much you'll teach.
Updated September 2026 · based on parent reviews and publisher information
Still torn? Answer a few questions and see how both rank for your child, side by side.
Compare for my child| Mystery Science | Generation Genius | |
|---|---|---|
| Grades | K–5th | K–8th |
| Creation/faith | No religious content; teaches evolution | No religious content; teaches evolution |
| Approach | Video-led inquiry lessons with hands-on activities and discussion | Video lessons with discussion questions, worksheets and DIY activities |
| Who teaches | The program does the teaching | The program does the teaching |
| Parent prep | Low to moderate (open and go; gather household supplies ahead) | Low (press play; some activities need gathered supplies) |
| Screen time | A mix of screen and paper | Online |
| Video lessons | Included: every lesson is taught by a video host | Included: each lesson centers on a teaching video |
| Cost | $179: Homeschool Mystery Science membership for one year (posted sale price; list $199) | $325: Homeschool plan, one year (science + math + ELA bundle; only homeschool plan listed) |
| Parents love |
|
|
| Common complaints |
|
|
Parents describe it as the elementary science that actually gets done: kids love the question-first videos and remember the activities long afterward. Many treat it as enough science for K–2 or K–3, but it is not a complete program for older kids. The main complaint is that it feels too light and a bit scattered by grades 4–5, so families add a textbook or switch to a fuller curriculum.
Families say kids look forward to the professionally made videos and that it works well for siblings watching together. Most reviewers call it a strong supplement rather than a complete science curriculum, especially past the early grades. The common criticisms are shallow depth, a flashy style some kids find overstimulating, and a steep price increase.
Neither is better for every child. Mystery Science is the stronger fit for hands-on unit studies; some screen time. Generation Genius is the stronger fit for online; minimal.
Mystery Science: no religious content; teaches evolution. Generation Genius: no religious content; teaches evolution.
Mystery Science: $179: Homeschool Mystery Science membership for one year (posted sale price; list $199). Generation Genius: $325: Homeschool plan, one year (science + math + ELA bundle; only homeschool plan listed).
Summaries are in our own words.